Magabala Books Australia’s leading First Nations publisher

We respectfully caution Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers that this website contains images of people who have passed away.

Close

Verbal Submission | UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

Tue, Nov 17, 2026

Dr Albert Barume 

UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

Magabala Books  

Verbal Submission | Broome Speakers Forum  

Re: Legislation guardrails to mitigate the risks facing First Nations people and communities in the face of extractive Artificial Intelligence (AI) practices

Giinagay in my language and ngaji mingan in the language of Yawuru Country. I am Dr Lilly Brown. A Gumbaynngirr woman whose family belongs to the mid-north coast of New South Wales, with connections to the south coast on Yuin Country. I am a guest here on the unceded lands of the Yawuru people, I acknowledge Elders of this place past and present. 

I am here to present to you in my capacity as the CEO of Magabala Books Aboriginal Corporation. Thank you Dr Barume for this opportunity to provide a statement today. I also acknowledge my colleague, Magabala’s Program and Impact Manager, Bardi, Jabirr Jabirr and Yawuru woman, Alarna Maher and the ongoing work of Dr Patrick Dodson, who is also present today.  

Magabala Books is Australia’s leading First Nations publishing house. As one of the most remote publishing houses in the world, for almost 40 years we have carried stories across Country, across generations, and across worlds; nurturing voices, protecting cultural knowledge, and creating space for First Nations storytellers to be seen, heard, and valued.

As a snapshot, since 2022, Magabala has experienced transformative growth. In addition to the publication of 67 new titles, we have nurtured writers and illustrators through our creative and cultural development programs and made a significant economic contribution to the creative industries, paying out $2.1 million dollars in royalties, and $375k in grants directly to First Nations people. Our creators’ excellence was recognised with longlisted, shortlisted and winning titles in every national state and territory award, including the Prime Ministers’ Literary Award, the Miles Franklin Award and the Stella Prize. 

This profound success – economic, creative, and social, is a testament to the foresight of Magabala’s founding Elders and community members, who almost four decades ago established Magabala as an Aboriginal community controlled publishing house to keep First Nations stories safe; to ensure that the cultural and intellectual property of First Nations people was protected and that Aboriginal people would be recognised and remunerated for the stories they shared in published form. 

 In 2026, this profound vision is at risk. In March of last year, Magabala was alerted that Meta, the multinational company that owns Facebook, Whatsapp and Instagram – worth over $2 trillion Australian dollars, had scraped more than 37 Magabala titles to train their artificial intelligence or AI system – without creators prior and informed consent, without fair pay and recognition. Books stolen included Yorro Yorro: Everything Standing Up Alive by the late David Mowjarlai, a book of revered cultural significance, and other stories grown from the Kimberley region such as Jandamarra and the Bunuba Resistance and Black Cockatoo coauthored by Jaru and Kija man Carl Merrison.

These stories and those like them, whether in published form, art on canvas or any other medium, carry the knowledge, histories and voices of our people. 3 They are assertions of story sovereignty. When that material is extracted without consent, it raises questions that go beyond conventional copyright.  

Under current Australian copyright laws, these creators and their families have no recourse despite the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), outlining the right of First Nations people and communities to maintain, control and protect our knowledge and cultural expression. The actions of  Meta and other extractive AI companies undermine these rights.  

These actions directly contravene several articles under UNDRIP including: 

  • Article 3 – Our right to self-determination, including determining how our stories and knowledge are accessed, used and shared. 

  • Article 11 – Our right to practise and revitalise cultural traditions, including redress for cultural property taken without free, prior and informed consent 

  • Articles 18 and 19 – Our rights to participate in decisions affecting us, particularly relevant as Australia develops its approach to AI regulation. 

  • Article 31 – Our right to maintain, control, protect and develop cultural heritage, traditional knowledge and expressions, including intellectual property. Yet Australia's copyright framework doesn't adequately recognise collective ICIP rights or cultural authority. 

  • Article 32 – Our right to determine priorities for the development and use of our lands, territories and resources. There's an important connection here to knowledge originating from Country and the cultural responsibilities attached to it.  

First Nations creators should hold the right to say no. First Nations creators and storytellers should be compensated for their stories and knowledge, IF they say yes.  

We welcome the Albanese government’s proposed mandatory national framework set to be implemented in 2027, which details strict controls around AI, yet this framework to date does not mention ICIP. 4 Existing intellectual property legislation is also limited, and leaves Indigenous knowledge, including creative and cultural, critically exposed to AI exploitatioThere are models that have been developed for the Australian government to in part mitigate the risks we face, such as Copyright Plus: A Framework to Protect Australian Creators from AI Related Harms, developed by University of New South Wales Professor Kathy Bowey and her team.

The development of AI technologies is occurring at a seemingly irrepressible, and thus alarming, rate. 

As we fight to protect the cultural and intellectual property of First Nations storytellers and creators, we call on all Australian governments to: 

  • Implement the six recommendations put forward by the 2023 UNDRIP Inquiry led by dr Patrick Dodson, including the development of a National Action Plan

  • Further, and in line with the inquiry's recommendations, embed robust guardrails in copyright legalisation to protect the rights of First Nations people from the extractive practices of AI companies who have no accountability, legislative or otherwise, to the communities they steal from.  

I want to briefly quote from Dr Terri Janke, expert on ICIP.  She says: 

AI got no Dreaming.  AI doesn’t know protocols. It doesn’t discern that one story belongs to one Country and should not be used to refer to another Country – land, seas, waters, kin and people. Such re-positioning of a story without cultural authority is a cultural transgression.

For Magabala, we were established as a response to centuries of non-Indigenous folk stealing knowledge and stories, we are fierce in our advocacy and through our publishing practice to counter this extraction, yet given the pace of advances in AI, and the governments lack of reassurance in alignment with UNDRIP, we feel acutely that AI - so wholly untethered from place or held in relation, is a continuation of colonial theft and extraction.